Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast

33. The One with Poisonings, Cemeteries, and Hauntings

What do an old insane asylum and an abandoned playground have in common? A history of poisonings, eerie cemeteries, and lots of spooky ghost stories. We’re both bringing you stories today, starting with the Oregon Insane Asylum and then heading down south to stop at Dead Children’s Playground in Alabama. Burn your sage after this one!

32. The One with the Ultimate Catfish

Disgruntled ex + Tinder + Craigslist = What could go wrong? Michelle Hadley was arrested for planning the rape of her ex’s new boo, but did she do it? Someone call Nev and Max, we have the ultimate catfish story. 

31. The One with Suspected Serial Killer Herb Baumeister

Wholesome, pure, all-American: Herb Baumeister wanted you to think he was many things, but a suspected serial killer? Known as the I70 Killer or the Fox Hollow Farm Killer, he had many secrets in his metaphorical closet. 

30. The One with Cranky, Crazy Amy Bishop

Don’t call her crazy though! Amy Bishop literally (and allegedly) got away with murder as a teenager, and let’s just say she definitely didn’t learn her lesson. This one will have you wondering how nobody saw this coming. 

29. The Attempted Assassination of Ronald Reagan

History class is now in session! Since the kids are out of school, we’re taking over as your humble instructors today and debriefing you on the attempted assassination of our 40th president. 

28. The One with the Demon House

Breaking up your COVID-19 boredom with some hauntings, exorcism, and a ton of demons. Also known as “The 200 Demons House,” this Gary, Indiana home is known for being so spooky the last owner opted to destroy it all together. Settle in for some ghost stories, quarantining Murder Lovers! 

27. The One Where Mary Vincent Fights Like Hell

Need a break from the Coronavirus stress? We’re bringing you zero peace of mind with the most stressful (but amazing) survival story of Mary Vincent, who was brutally attacked by Lawrence Singleton at just 15 years old. As we always say, don’t get in vans with strangers. 

26. The One with Daphne Wright’s “Hacked” Crime Scene

What do you get with an electric chainsaw and some blue paint? Basically the worst crime scene cover up ever. Dubbed a “love triangle gone wrong,” we’re setting the record straight on what happened between Daphne Wright, her ex Sallie Collins, and innocent (and platonic) victim Darlene VanderGiesen.

25. The One with the Greyhound Bus Beheading

If we’ve learned anything, it’s that you’re not yourself when you’re hungry and off your meds. Vince Li proved bus rage is a real thing when he attacked and killed Tim McLean, but did the punishment fit the crime?

24. The One Where Nathaniel Bar-Jonah Should Eat a Snickers

BYOBurgers to cookouts from here on out! Convicted child molester, possible serial killer, maybe a cannibal? Basically, this guy has the whole package. Beware of strangers serving up some suspect barbecue in their backyards, Murder Lovers!